So last night was it. The biggest wrestling event of the year: Wrestlemania. I'm going to be podcasting about it at length with my long suffering wife (gawd bless her) but I wanted to put out some initial thoughts about the Artist Formerly Known as The Granddaddy of Them All. Spoilers ahead!
IC Title Ladder match:
This was a great way to start the show. High energy, crazy bumps, and a nice fast pace made sure that the crowd were into this the whole way through. In a ladder match, there's always the danger that something will go wrong, some ladder tilting a little too much, someone having to reposition quickly, but nothing stands out as an issue at all. Loved seeing Sami Zayn and KO facing off, as ever, and Sin Cara had both of the biggest spots in the match. Great to see a complete swerve with Zack Ryder winning, putting the seed of doubt in people's minds that the show wouldn't finish as obviously as they'd suspected. As much as I love KO, it makes sense to take the belt off him, as he's a strong enough character to not need the belt, especially going into what will hopefully be a nice long feud with Sami Zayn.
Jericho/Styles:
Having fought each other several times before, I was surprised this didn't have some kind of stipulation on it to differentiate it from what has come before. As it was, whilst the match was good, and built to a nice crescendo of near falls, it felt a little played out, and was a little sloppy in parts. It feels mean to be too harsh on them, because this was still a very serviceable match, but it needed a little bit of something extra to make it a Wrestlemania match. Also, I'm not 100% on the logic of having AJ Styles lose his first Wrestlemania match, but again, not a huge problem for me.
New Day/League of Nations:
I doubt many people were salivating at the prospect of this match. The New Day are good, but are still in the midst of their Face turn, and haven't really adapted their style to be out and out good guys. And the League of Nations is a mess. Classic 'we don't know what else to do with them' booking, making jobbers of some very solid, formerly main-event level wrestlers. They either needed to be pushed as a massive faction of monster heels and kill everyone, or give up. The former isn't happening, so let's hope the latter does. The match was solid, if forgettable, and like the Y2AJ match was too similar to many matches we've seen on TV in recent weeks. The League of Nations won, and then everyone moved on with their lives. Almost immediately in fact, as the WWE legends Stone Cold, HBK and Mick Foley came out to decimate the full time wrestlers WWE wants us to take seriously. It baffles and annoyed me in equal measure how much WWE is willing to sacrifice in the name of nostalgia. I understand people love seeing the old guys, but they didn't need to beat anyone up, and even if they did could they not beat up The Social Outcasts, already comedy characters? No, three men, all of whom are in their 50s, easily dismantled 3 upper mid-card wrestlers, who themselves had just won a match over 3 other wrestlers. How far down the pecking order does that push The New Day? Annoying and without merit.
Street Fight:
Now this was always going to be something of a disappointment. For me, when the words 'Street Fight' are mentioned, my mind immediately races back 16 years to the Royal Rumble match between Triple H and Cactus Jack, an absolute classic. There was blood, barbed wire, thumbtacks and carnage. It was amazing. Now with us being in the PG era, that was never going to be what we got today. Which begs the question why make this a street fight in the first place? Why bother setting up the barbed wire baseball bat and a chainsaw in the prior weeks if we know there's absolutely no way that they'll be used? As it was, this was a fun match, featuring Brock flinging Dean Ambrose around like a stuffed animal, and Dean desperately trying to fight his way back. Whether I think it told the right story or not, a story was definitely told, which means I enjoyed it. It could have gone a little longer, and (whilst I've never been a big one for blood in wrestling) I feel like it definitely would have added an extra level to this match to see one or both of them wearing the ol' crimson mask, I enjoyed this.
Women's Championship match:
Going in, I suspected this might be the match of the night, and I wasn't disappointed. Aside from a couple of botches, all 3 women worked incredibly hard here, had some great spots, and kept the pace right up for the majority. Becky especially looked phenomenal, which was needed as she'd been built up in the last few weeks the weakest. Again, there are slight niggles (I would have preferred a new champion, and definitely a clean victory without Old Man Flair getting involved) but this was magic. Easily the best match of the event, and one of the better triple threat matches I've ever seen.
Hell in a Cell:
This was the biggest headscratcher going into the event, with both competitors being faces with a lot to lose. Who were we supposed to get behind? If Taker wins, The Authority stay in control of RAW and the great change that Shane has been talking about for weeks doesn't come to pass. If Shane wins, The Undertaker doesn't have any more Wrestlemania matches. It was lose/lose, and that made for an awkward crowd response. This is making me sound like a completely depraved blood-lover, which I'm not, but I do feel like a Hell in a Cell without blood damages the impact of the match type. It's supposed to be one of the most foreboding match types there is, it should be a war inside the cage. For them to finish the match just tired means it's not that different from any other match. That aside, it felt like the story they were telling was that Taker was dominant, but because of Shane's indomitable will, he couldn't keep him down for 3, but it was a little blurry, and Shane had too much offense. Ultimately, as everyone knew it would, the match spilled out and Shane jumped off the cage. He's entirely insane, but it looked amazing. And then Taker won. It was all a little anticlimactic, which seems odd to say after someone took a 25 foot bump, but Shane came back with such momentum, to have him lose is a real mystery. I'm confident there'll be more said on RAW, but on the night it was a little strange.
Battle Royal:
This was the piss break match everyone thought it would be, but a few things cropped up:
Entrances. If you're only giving entrances to a few people, make sure the guy who wins is one of them, especially if he's a surprise entrant. See also: Tatanka.
Damian Sandow: The biggest loser in a night full of them. How bad do management have to think of you to get eliminated immediately by a non-wrestler?
Darren Young: This is 2016. Don't ever do a back rake again. Just... no.
The Rock kills time:
I love The Rock. He's one of my favourite all time wrestlers, and I totally understand the WWE wanting to cash in on his ridiculous success. I don't begrudge him being there, I don't even begrudge him wasting 10 minutes setting his name on fire with a huge flamethrower. The event is 5 hours long, there's a lot of time wasting. Also, if I'm honest, him wrestling someone unannounced was worth it just to get him ripping his stripper trousers off to reveal his wresatling gear underneath (is the implication that he is ALWAYS ready for a match?) But why oh why do you need to offer up the Wyatt Family as a sacrifice for him? Aren't there other people? And if they are to face him, at least let them beat him down before Cena makes the save. Give them SOME strength. But no, again they are shrugged off as an afterthought. I love Bray Wyatt, and it does annoy me to see WWE once again proving they have no idea what to do with him. I feel like he needs to leave for a bit, get off TV, give people time to forget him, retool the character, recruit some more people. Just something!
Main event:
Everybody Hates Roman. I do feel bad for him, because the majority of the scorn is nothing to do with him, more just what WWE are doing with him, but people don't hold back in letting him know how they feel. Again, this was a lose/lose situation for the fans. If Roman wins, he's still not proven himself as a reliable main event face presence. If HHH wins, it hurts the company (in the same way they've done twice already in this event) by claiming that an old wrestler can come out of retirement and be a genuine world champion again because no one on the current roster can hold a candle to the old guys. So they were onto a loser from the start, and didn't do themselves any favours by booking the match at such a slow pace at the end of a 5 hour event. I imagine it was done to protect both Roman (who might not be able to work a fast paced match yet) and Hunter (who is, as much as WWE doesn't want us to realise, 46 years old). It was an only-ok match headlining the biggest event of the year featuring a good guy no one likes. It was never going to work. But to their credit, the finish was good (good lord Steph took that spear like a boss).
Overall:
Not great. There were highlights (women's match, Shane's bump, IC title match) but not enough to mark this out as a great card.
As I say though, I'll be podcasting about this in the next few days hopefully, on my brand new wrestling podcast, so stay tuned for some more detailed thoughts!